How Far In Advance should I order?

We recommend at least 48 hours notice, but larger or themed cakes benefit from more lead time. If you need a cake in a shorter time frame, call us to see if we are able to accommodate the order.

Do you offer cakes for weddings and events?

Yes. we create tiered and specialty cakes for weddings, showers, anniversaries, and other celebrations. You can book a cake tasting here. Tier cakes are priced by the slice.

What affects the final price of a custom cake?

The final price of a custom cake is based on several factors, including size, number of servings, level of detail, design complexity, and time required to create it. More detailed designs take additional time to plan and execute, and our pricing ensures we can fairly compensate our talented baking and decorating staff while maintaining high-quality ingredients.

Do you use fondant on your custom cakes?

Some design elements may include fondant accents or decorative pieces, but unless fondant is specifically requested, our custom cakes are typically finished in buttercream. We do not offer fully fondant-covered cakes. Fondant details require additional time and skill, so fondant accents or decorative pieces include an extra charge.

Can you copy a design exactly?

We use inspiration photos as a starting point rather than an exact blueprint. Each custom cake is made by hand, and while we do our very best to capture the overall feel, style, and vibe of your inspiration, custom cakes are a form of art. Colors, textures, and details may vary slightly, making each cake truly one of a kind.

Custom Cakes in Lancaster, PA

ORDER NOW: Lancaster PA Custom Cakes

Looking to celebrate a special event with a cake that perfectly fits the occasion? From buttercream designs, to in-depth Pinterest Creations, our team would love to help you create a cake that becomes a part of your memories.

How to Order Your Custom Cake
Our custom cakes are specifically made-to-order just for you and require at least 24 - 48 hours lead time. To order your custom cake, simply fill out our order form linked above or call us at (717) 492-8440. We’ll discuss your size, flavor, design, and timeline — then confirm with you. Custom cakes require at least 24–48 hours lead time and longer for tiered or event designs

Cake Flavors: French Vanilla, white, yellow, chocolate, marble, red velvet, carrot, spice, coconut, lemon, & funfetti, Gluten Free Chocolate, Gluten Free White

Filling Flavors: Ganache, raspberry mousse, lemon mousse, raspberry, chocolate fudge, white chocolate mousse, chocolate mousse, strawberry mousse, and coconut mousse

Frosting: Buttercream, sweet, peanut butter, chocolate buttercream, cream cheese

Check out some of our past creations below!

Serving Lancaster County and Nearby Areas

Lancaster
Mount Joy
Manheim Township
Elizabethtown
Hempfield
Landisville
Donegal

Rise Bake Shoppe is a from-scratch bakery located in Mount Joy, PA, proudly serving Lancaster County, including Lancaster City and surrounding communities.

A pink birthday cake decorated with roses and a picture of a door on the side, with a message that says 'Happy 5th Birthday' at the bottom. This is a custom decorated birthday cake at Rise Bake Shoppe made with homemade buttercream icing.

Custom Cake in Lancaster decorated to look like a hamburger with icing to resemble buns, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and a hamburger patty.

A black Halloween-themed cake decorated with black frosting, spiderweb designs, and pearl-like accents. Custom cakes in Lancaster PA

A medical-themed cake decorated with fondant doctor tools including a stethoscope, syringe, pills, and a clipboard. The cake also has handwritten text on a scroll. Custom Cakes in Lancaster

A two-tier wedding cake in Lancaster with white frosting and pinkish-red layers, topped with a silver letter 'B' cake topper. The cake is surrounded by pink flowers in glass vases on a decorated table with petal accents.

A round custom cake decorated with pink and white icing, pink drip decoration, and pink and green frosting flowers on top and around the base.

A two-tiered cake decorated with a pastel purple and blue watercolor design, featuring an edible image of Ariel from The Little Mermaid, seashells, seaweed, and ocean-themed accents. Best custom cakes in Lancaster

Pink birthday cake with pink and white roses, decorated as a fairy tale castle with a brown door, on a white cake base with a birthday message written in pink. Custom decorated cakes in Lancaster

Chocolate cake decorated with chocolate frosting, chocolate chunks, and white and dark chocolate candies, with a chocolate glaze drizzling down the sides. Custom buttercream cakes in Lancaster for pick up today

Your Questions, Answered

We recommend at least 48 hours notice, but larger or themed cakes benefit from more lead time. If you need a cake in a shorter time frame, call us to see if we are able to accommodate the order.
Yes. we create tiered and specialty cakes for weddings, showers, anniversaries, and other celebrations. You can book a cake tasting here. Tier cakes are priced by the slice.
We use inspiration photos as a starting point rather than an exact blueprint. Each custom cake is made by hand, and while we do our very best to capture the overall feel, style, and vibe of your inspiration, custom cakes are a form of art. Colors, textures, and details may vary slightly, making each cake truly one of a kind.
The final price of a custom cake is based on several factors, including size, number of servings, level of detail, design complexity, and time required to create it. More detailed designs take additional time to plan and execute, and our pricing ensures we can fairly compensate our talented baking and decorating staff while maintaining high-quality ingredients.
Some design elements may include fondant accents or decorative pieces, but unless fondant is specifically requested, our custom cakes are typically finished in buttercream. We do not offer fully fondant-covered cakes. Fondant details require additional time and skill, so fondant accents or decorations include an extra charge.